I always rather enjoyed the orange skin cap. However, this fiasco reminds us that when something isn't broken, don't try to fix it. Also it's a reminder of how good design really does matter to consumers, whether or not they realize it.
The new design carried many of the same hallmarks of the Pepsi redesign which the Arnell Group also executed — san serif typefaces, plenty of open space, and the apparent aim of trying to make everything look like an iPod. This type of design style simply doesn't translate to food products.
I really like the design and new packaging, but when it comes to his explanation, as much as its interesting to see how they came up with the idea, but as a consumer would they be able to make all those relations and notions?
Apparently the so-much-praised "Less is more" didn't quite worked well for them :)
Sometimes less is just..less. The new packaging was what "web 2.0 style " is right now - overused, boring and eventually it will fade in couple of years.
I interacted with this design as a consumer when it was first launched but I never saw the squeezable rounded orange cap. It probably wasn't sold that in this part of the States. The concept makes sense but understand (1) how it would have gotten lost especially with the wrong cap or (2) people didn't care and focused on the graphic work.
It is also a pretty big shift from the original. Maybe a slower evolution would have worked better?
I plugged a link to this page in my latest blog post, Brand New? Just wanted to let you know. You can read my article here: http://dougdraws.com/brand-new/
Very interesting to hear all the emotion that was used to pitch the idea and concept. Too bad that wasn't reflected by the design. I have to think the Tropicana folks saw the container and thought how boring it was only to be swept away by the imagery of the pitch. Honestly, I never saw most of what he talked about until he mentioned it.
Peter Arnell did himself and his company a really bad favor with this press conference. I honestly wonder how this guy made so big in NY.
I like the new packaging but it is an iPod compared to the predecesor. That squeeze cap Peter loves so much is fun but his squeeze philosophy is fill of BS.
6 CommentsThoughts from the Community